Invoice Factoring
Invoice factoring is a financial transaction where a business sells its accounts receivable (invoices) to a third party (called a factor) at a discount. This provides the business with immediate cash flow, rather than waiting for customers to pay their invoices.
Here's how it works:
The business provides goods or services to its customers and issues invoices.
The business sells these invoices to a factoring company.
The factoring company pays the business a percentage of the invoice value upfront (typically 80-90%). This is the discounted value, as the factoring company takes a fee for its services.
The customers then pay the factoring company directly.
Once the factoring company receives full payment from the customers, it pays the remaining balance to the business, minus its fees.
Benefits of invoice factoring:
Improved cash flow: Businesses get immediate access to cash, which can be used for operational expenses, investments, or paying down debts.
Reduced credit risk: In some cases (non-recourse factoring), the factoring company assumes the risk of customers not paying their invoices.
Outsourced collections: The factoring company handles the collection of payments, freeing up the business's time and resources.
No impact on credit score: Factoring is not a loan, so it doesn't appear on the business's credit report.
Drawbacks of invoice factoring:
Cost: Factoring companies charge fees, which can eat into the business's profits.
Loss of control: The business loses control over the collection process and customer relationships.
Customer perception: Some customers may view factoring negatively, as it can be seen as a sign of financial distress.
Invoice factoring is a useful financing tool for businesses that need to improve their cash flow and are willing to pay a fee for this service. It is particularly common in industries with long payment cycles, such as manufacturing, construction, and transportation.
It's important to note that invoice factoring is different from invoice financing. In invoice financing, the business uses its invoices as collateral for a loan, but it still remains responsible for collecting payments from customers.
Factoring Licence
Companies conducting regulated activities under the Securities and Futures Act (SFA) in Singapore must hold a Capital Markets Services (CMS) license, unless exempt. Whether an invoice factoring company ("Operator") needs a CMS license depends on its business model, including its activities and transaction terms.
No CMS License Required (Simple Invoice Factoring):
An Operator does not need a CMS license if its invoice factoring involves:
A creditor (e.g., a merchant) assigning its right to receive payment from a customer (under an invoice for goods/services) to the Operator.
The Operator paying the creditor for these rights.
The customer's contractual obligation to pay the Operator directly.
This is a simple sale of contractual rights to receive payment. The invoices themselves are not considered "securities" under the SFA in this scenario, so a CMS license is not required.
CMS License Required (Debenture Issuance):
An Operator does need a CMS license if its invoice factoring involves:
A creditor assigning its right to receive payment to the Operator (as above).
The Operator paying the creditor.
Critically, the Operator then entering into agreements with investors where the investors lend money to the Operator, and the Operator promises repayment (with or without interest/premium).
These agreements with investors create debentures, which are classified as "securities" under Section 2(1) of the SFA. Because the Operator is issuing and dealing in securities (debentures) to fund its operations, it requires a CMS license.
Key takeaway: If the Operator simply buys and collects on invoices, no license is needed. However, if the Operator raises funds by issuing debt instruments like debentures to investors, a CMS license is mandatory.
This explanation clarifies when an operator facilitating invoice factoring needs a Capital Markets Services (CMS) license in Singapore under the Securities and Futures Act (SFA). Here's a breakdown:
Scenario 1: No CMS License Required (Typical Invoice Factoring)
Process:
A creditor (e.g., a business) sells its right to receive payment from a customer (based on an invoice for goods/services) to the Operator. This is an assignment of contractual rights.
The Operator pays the creditor for these rights.
The customer is now obligated to pay the Operator directly.
Why no license? This is a simple sale and purchase of contractual rights. The invoice itself represents a debt obligation, but it's not considered a "security" under the SFA in this context. Therefore, dealing with these invoices in this straightforward manner doesn't require a CMS license.
Scenario 2: CMS License Required (Debenture Creation)
Process:
The creditor sells its right to receive payment from a customer to the Operator (as in Scenario 1).
Crucially, the Operator then enters into a separate agreement with investors. These investors lend money to the Operator. The Operator promises to repay this loan, potentially with interest or a premium.
Why a license? The agreement between the Operator and the investors creates a debenture. A debenture is a type of debt instrument, and under the SFA, it is considered a "security." Because the Operator is now issuing and dealing with securities (debentures), they need a CMS license for dealing in capital market products that are securities.
Key Difference:
The critical distinction is whether the Operator is simply buying and collecting on invoices (Scenario 1) or creating its own debt instruments (debentures) to fund its invoice factoring activities (Scenario 2). The creation of debentures triggers the licensing requirement.
In short: If the Operator's financing comes from investors through debt instruments like debentures, a CMS license is required. If the Operator is simply purchasing and collecting on invoices, it is not.
How Bestar can Help
Factoring Licence
Bestar can help businesses in Singapore with various aspects of setting up and operating an invoice factoring company. Here's how we can assist:
1. Setting Up a Factoring Company in Singapore:
Regulatory Compliance: Bestar can advise on the necessary licenses and permits required from the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA). We can ensure compliance with all relevant financial services regulations and assist in drafting legal documents like contracts, agreements, and policies.
Corporate Structure: Bestar can recommend the most suitable legal structure for your factoring company (e.g., private limited company) and assist with company incorporation and registration.
Business Planning: Bestar can help develop a comprehensive business plan outlining your target market, services, pricing strategy, risk management, and financial projections.
Risk Management: Bestar can help evaluate the financial risks associated with factoring and develop risk mitigation strategies. They can also implement credit assessment procedures to assess the creditworthiness of clients and debtors.
2. Ongoing Support for Factoring Businesses:
Financial Professionals: Bestar can provide financial professionals to assist with various aspects of the business, such as accounting, bookkeeping, and financial analysis.
Risk Assessment: Bestar can provide ongoing risk assessment services to help the factoring company manage its portfolio and minimize losses.
Why Choose Bestar?
Expertise: Bestar has expertise in navigating the complex regulations and requirements for setting up and operating a factoring company in Singapore.
Risk Mitigation: Bestar can help mitigate risks by implementing effective risk management strategies and credit assessment procedures.
Financial Performance: Bestar can help optimize financial performance by providing financial professionals and ongoing support.
By engaging the expertise of Bestar, you can increase your chances of establishing a successful factoring company in Singapore.
Comments