Complex Consolidation Example Involving Goodwill, Deferred Taxes, and Foreign Currency Translation

Complex Consolidation Example Involving Goodwill, Deferred Taxes, and Foreign Currency Translation | Bestar

Consolidating International Subsidiary

Complex Consolidation Example Involving Goodwill, Deferred Taxes, and Foreign Currency Translation

Scenario:

Parent Company (US-based) acquires 80% of Subsidiary Company (Euro-based) on January 1, 20X1. The functional currency of the Subsidiary is the Euro (€).

Key Data:

• Acquisition Date: January 1, 20X1

• Exchange Rate on Acquisition Date: $1.20/€

• Consideration Paid: $480 million

• Fair Value of Subsidiary's Net Assets: €350 million

• Subsidiary's Book Value of Net Assets: €300 million

• Deferred Tax Liability (DTL) in Subsidiary's Books: €50 million (related to temporary differences that will reverse in the future)

• Goodwill Impairment at the End of 20X1: $10 million

Consolidation Steps:

1. Translate Subsidiary's Financial Statements:

   
   

   • Translate assets and liabilities at the exchange rate prevailing on the balance sheet date.

   • Translate income statement items using the average exchange rate for the period.

   • Translate dividends at the exchange rate on the date of payment.

     
     

2. Eliminate Intercompany Transactions:

   
   

   • Remove intercompany sales and purchases.

   • Remove intercompany dividends.

     
     

3. Consolidate:

   
   

   • Combine the Parent's and Subsidiary's translated financial statements line-by-line.

     
     

4. Adjust for Non-controlling Interest (NCI):

   
   

   • Allocate the total acquisition differential (consideration paid minus fair value of net assets acquired) between the parent and NCI based on ownership percentages.

   • Recognize NCI's share of the Subsidiary's net income and equity.

     
     

5. Consolidate Goodwill:

   
   

   • Calculate goodwill as the excess of the consideration paid over the fair value of the net assets acquired.

   • Allocate goodwill between the parent and NCI.

   • Impair goodwill if necessary.

     
     

6. Consolidate Deferred Taxes:

   
   

   • Recognize the DTL at the exchange rate on the balance sheet date.

   • Adjust the DTL for any changes in exchange rates since acquisition.

Example:

Let's assume the following exchange rates at the end of 20X1:

• Balance Sheet Date: $1.15/€

• Average Rate for the Year: $1.18/€

Consolidation Entries:

• Translation of Subsidiary's Financial Statements:

  • Debit Assets (translated at year-end rate)

  • Credit Liabilities (translated at year-end rate)

  • Credit Equity (translated at historical rate)

  • Credit Translation Adjustment (for the difference)

• Elimination of Intercompany Transactions:

  • Make journal entries to remove intercompany transactions.

• Consolidation of Income Statement:

  • Combine the Parent's and Subsidiary's income statements (Subsidiary's translated using the average rate).

• Consolidation of Balance Sheet:

  • Combine the Parent's and Subsidiary's balance sheets (Subsidiary's translated at year-end rate).

• NCI Adjustment:

  • Allocate the acquisition differential and net income between the parent and NCI.

• Goodwill Consolidation:

  • Record goodwill as the excess of consideration paid over fair value of net assets acquired.

  • Allocate goodwill between the parent and NCI.

  • Record goodwill impairment.

• Deferred Tax Consolidation:

  • Record the DTL at the year-end exchange rate.

  • Adjust the DTL for exchange rate changes.

Note:

This is a simplified example. In practice, consolidation can be more complex, involving factors such as:

• Differences in accounting methods between the parent and subsidiary.

• Complex tax structures.

• Multiple currencies.

• Business combinations involving more than two entities.

Key Considerations and Further Details

1. Goodwill Impairment:

• Impairment Test: Goodwill is tested for impairment annually. If the carrying amount of goodwill exceeds its implied fair value, an impairment loss is recognized.

• Fair Value Estimation: Various methods are used to estimate goodwill's fair value, such as the discounted cash flow method or the relief from royalty method.

2. Deferred Taxes:

• Temporary Differences: These arise when the carrying amount of an asset or liability in the financial statements differs from its tax base.

• DTL Reversal: As temporary differences reverse, the DTL will be recognized as an income tax expense.

• Exchange Rate Effects: Changes in exchange rates can impact the translation of the DTL, leading to adjustments in the consolidated financial statements.

3. Foreign Currency Translation:

• Functional Currency: The currency of the primary economic environment in which the entity operates.

• Reporting Currency: The currency in which the parent company prepares its financial statements.

• Translation Methods: Different methods are used for translating assets, liabilities, income statement items, and dividends, depending on their nature and the functional currency.

4. Other Factors:

• Minority Interests: The non-controlling interest's share of the subsidiary's net income and equity must be appropriately recognized.

• Intercompany Transactions: Elimination of intercompany transactions is crucial to avoid double-counting and present a consolidated view of the group's performance.

• Accounting Standards: International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) 1  have specific requirements for consolidation, including goodwill impairment, deferred taxes, and foreign currency translation.   

  
  

Illustrative Example:

Let's expand on the previous example by considering a specific temporary difference:

• Subsidiary owns equipment with a carrying amount of €100 million and a tax base of €80 million. This results in a temporary difference of €20 million.

• Assuming a tax rate of 30%, the initial DTL recognized would be €6 million (€20 million * 30%).

At the end of 20X1:

• The equipment's tax base has decreased to €70 million due to depreciation.

• The temporary difference has increased to €30 million.

• The DTL should be adjusted to reflect this change, resulting in an additional DTL of €3 million (€10 million * 30%).

Consolidation Journal Entry:

Dr. Deferred Tax Liability - Subsidiary €3 million
Cr. Income Tax Expense €3 million

This entry reflects the increase in the DTL due to the change in the temporary difference.

Note:

This is a simplified illustration. In practice, the calculations can be more complex, especially when dealing with multiple temporary differences, changing tax rates, and fluctuating exchange rates.

By carefully considering these factors and applying the appropriate accounting standards, companies can accurately consolidate their financial statements and provide a comprehensive view of their financial performance and position.

How Bestar SG can Help

Complex Consolidation Example Involving Goodwill, Deferred Taxes, and Foreign Currency Translation

Bestar, with its expertise in accounting, finance, and advisory services, can provide valuable assistance in navigating the complexities of consolidation, including those involving goodwill, deferred taxes, and foreign currency translation. Here's how we can help:   

1. Comprehensive Understanding of Consolidation Principles:

• Bestar's professionals possess in-depth knowledge of Singapore Financial Reporting Standards (FRSs), including FRS 103 "Consolidated Financial Statements," which govern the consolidation process.

• We understand the key principles of consolidation, such as control, elimination of intercompany transactions, and the recognition and measurement of goodwill, deferred taxes, and foreign currency translation.

2. Expertise in Goodwill Impairment Testing:

• Bestar can assist in performing the annual impairment test for goodwill, ensuring compliance with FRS 10 "Property, Plant and Equipment" and FRS 3 "Business Combinations."

• We can help determine the appropriate fair value of goodwill using various valuation methods, such as the discounted cash flow method or the relief from royalty method.

3. Guidance on Deferred Tax Accounting:

• Bestar can provide expert guidance on the accounting for deferred taxes, including the recognition, measurement, and presentation of deferred tax assets and liabilities.

• We can help assess the likelihood of deferred tax assets being realized and ensure compliance with FRS 12 "Income Taxes."

4. Assistance with Foreign Currency Translation:

• Bestar can help determine the functional currency of foreign subsidiaries and apply the appropriate translation methods for assets, liabilities, income statement items, and dividends.

• We can assist in accounting for exchange rate differences and their impact on the consolidated financial statements.

5. Practical Application of Consolidation Principles:

• Bestar can guide companies through the practical application of consolidation principles, including the preparation of consolidated financial statements and the disclosure of relevant information in the notes to the financial statements.   

• We can help address specific challenges and complexities that may arise in the consolidation process.   

6. Staying Updated with Accounting Standards:

• Bestar stays abreast of the latest developments in accounting standards, including changes to FRSs that may impact consolidation practices.

• We can advise clients on the implications of these changes and help them implement any necessary adjustments.

By leveraging Bestar's expertise in these areas, companies can ensure that their consolidated financial statements are prepared accurately and in accordance with FRSs, providing a clear and reliable picture of their financial performance and position.   

Request for Quote